In 2001, the Reverend Ken Collier decided to leave UUCPA and accept the call to be the settled minister of another congregation. UUCPA was fortunate to have the Reverend Kurt Kuhwald as its interim parish minister from September 2001 thru August 2003. In May of 2003, UUCPA voted to call the Reverend Amy Zucker to be its next parish minister. In August 2003, Reverend Zucker became UUCPA's fifth settled parish minister.
In 2006, UUCPA started recounting its history as a prelude to the 60th anniversary of the signing of the church’s charter.